aipla CBM covered business method review Director Andrei Iancu fee setting authority filing fee inter partes review IP News ipo IPR IPWatchdog Articles Articles issue fee Josh Malone maintenance fees Patent Public Advisory Committee Patent Trial and Appeal Board Patents Paul Morinville PGR post grant review PPAC PTAB Trials SAS Institute v. Iancu Technology Tony Scardino US Inventor USPTO

PPAC Fee Hearing Discusses Proposed Increases to Late Payments, AIA Trial Fees –

PPAC Fee Hearing Discusses Proposed Increases to Late Payments, AIA Trial Fees -

Brendan Hourigan, Director, USPTO’s Workplace of Planning and Price range

On Thursday, September sixth, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Workplace’s Patent Public Advisory Committee (PPAC) convened a gathering as a part of its rulemaking course of for adjusting patent charges underneath the authority granted to the USPTO underneath the America Invents Act (AIA). On the assembly, USPTO officers outlined their present proposed guidelines to increase charges for sure utility patent purposes, late cost expenses for upkeep charges and AIA trial charges which can improve because of current rulings by the U.S. Supreme Courtroom.

In his remarks, USPTO Director Andrei Iancu famous that the company first exercised its payment setting authority underneath the AIA again in 2013. He credited these payment changes with serving to to scale back each the patent software backlog and pedency occasions whereas additionally introducing charge reductions for small and micro entities. Though the second payment revision beneath the AIA went into impact this January, Iancu stated that the company was persevering with to take a look at payment revisions which might assist the USPTO make vital investments into upgrading the company’s IT techniques. He added that the present spherical of proposed charge revisions are anticipated to go into impact in 2021.

There are a few causes supporting the company’s choice to challenge a rise in sure charges in accordance to Tony Scardino, Appearing Deputy Director of the USPTO. A type of causes is inflation which will increase the prices of many assets yr after yr. The Supreme Courtroom’s determination this April in SAS Institute v. Iancu is one more reason behind the proposed charge will increase as the choice requires administrative patent judges (APJs) sitting on PTAB trials to determine the patentability of all claims challenged by petitioners. Scardino additionally spoke to the significance of sustaining an working reserve on the USPTO, which he stated serves the position of a line of credit score for the USPTO which the company can’t acquire in the identical approach that non-public, non-governmental entities can. Scardino stated that fiscal yr 2017 ended under the minimal working reserve degree and that projections for 2018, 2019 and 2020 have been additionally displaying expectations that the company’s reserve funds can be under that minimal degree.

“As recently as earlier this year, the government experienced two short-term shutdowns, and the USPTO was able to stay open during using our reserves. When any kind of cash flow risk presents itself, approximately 90 percent of USPTO spending is on things that we don’t want to cut or we can easily cut in the short term such as rent, paying our employees, or paying for contracts that support mission-critical initiatives. So when short-term spending cuts are needed, they almost always come from the areas where we have the most flexibility which are IT hardware replacement and software development.”

The USPTO’s proposed focused payment changes have been introduced on the PPAC assembly by Brendan Hourigan, Director of the USPTO’s Workplace of Planning and Price range. The best payment will increase from a proportion standpoint have been these will increase for late funds related to upkeep charges. The USPTO’s proposal included a 525 % improve for late upkeep charges on the three.5 yr, 7.5 yr and the 11.5 yr renewal durations, elevating late cost charges from $160 up to $1,000 for giant entities. Hourigan stated that this improve would deliver USPTO late cost charges into line with these charged by different workplaces and would encourage the on-time cost of upkeep charges, including that greater than 90 % of patent renewals already find yourself getting paid prior to the due date. Upkeep charges for unique and re-situation patents would additionally rise by $400 on the three.5 yr mark, by $160 on the 7.5 yr mark after which by $400 on the 11.5 yr mark; these will increase represented a 25 % rise in upkeep charges on the three.5 yr mark however solely a four % improve on the 7.5 and 11.5 yr marks. The proposal would additionally improve situation charges for utility and re-difficulty patents by 20 %, from $1,000 to $1,200 for both.


The USPTO can also be wanting to encourage patent candidates to file their purposes within the DOCX format by introducing a brand new surcharge for utility non-provisional purposes which might be filed in codecs aside from DOCX. This is able to introduce a brand new $400 payment for such purposes. In accordance to Hourigan, the choice to encourage DOCX-format filings is meant to simplify the sharing of software knowledge as DOCX information are XML-based mostly. Different codecs, akin to PDFs, have to be transformed to XML utilizing optical character recognition (OCR), a know-how which is a supply of potential errors.

When it comes to sheer dollars, the best payment will increase proposed by the USPTO are numerous will increase related to Patent Trial and Attraction Board (PTAB) proceedings. Throughout the board, AIA trial charges would improve by about 25 % beneath the USPTO’s proposals. If authorised, petitions difficult up to 20 claims in an inter partes evaluation (IPR) continuing would improve from $15,500 up to $19,500 with every declare in extra of 20 claims costing a further $375, a $75 improve over the present extra declare charges. IPR publish-establishment charges would improve from $15,000 up to $18,750 with a further $750 cost for every declare in extra of 20 claims. Petition charges for publish-grant assessment (PGR) and coated enterprise technique (CBM) assessment proceedings would bounce from $16,000 up to $20,000 with a further $475 cost for every challenged declare in extra of 20 claims. Publish-establishment charges for CBM and PGR would improve from $22,000 up to $27,500 with a further $1,050 charge for every challenged declare in extra of 20 claims.

The USPTO’s charge setting proposal additionally features a new cost for admitting counsel to the PTAB on a professional hac vice foundation. A one-time $250 cost would permit counsel to symbolize a celebration in proceedings on the PTAB during these proceedings, together with the “several years” which it might take for a continuing to go from petition to termination in conditions the place the case could also be appealed to after which remanded by the Federal Circuit. This charge is meant to shift the price of PTAB providers from general trial charges to the petitioning get together whereas enabling litigators who will not be registered to apply earlier than the PTAB however have in depth information of the subject material to seem in a trial.

Lisa Jorgenson, Government Director of AIPLA

Following the USPTO’s presentation on the PPAC assembly was a collection of scheduled testimony made by numerous public witnesses representing stakeholders within the U.S. patent system. Requests for additional info to justify sure charge will increase was a standard thread crossing the statements of those witnesses. Lisa Jorgenson, government director of the American Mental Property Regulation Affiliation (AIPLA), requested the company to higher justify the elevated surcharge for late upkeep charge funds in addition to the will increase to IPR and PGR trials. Jorgenson famous that a lot of the extra work required by SAS Institute would happen after the establishment determination and thus it’d make extra sense to divide the payment improve such that the pre-establishment charges bear much less of the rise than these charged submit-establishment. Roland McAndrews of the Mental Property House owners Affiliation (IPO) additionally sought further justification for the 525 % improve to the late cost surcharge for upkeep charges, noting that the will to encourage on-time funds alone didn’t help that improve.

Points with the rise to upkeep charges have been raised by Roger Burleigh, affiliate basic counsel for IP with Ericsson. Burleigh stated that a big analysis and improvement company resembling Ericsson, which holds round 45,000 international patent belongings, has to set a really giant price range for acquiring and sustaining patent grants making the company’s payment construction essential. Though the most important proportion of the rise for upkeep charges are utilized on the first renewal interval, Burleigh famous that many companies don’t know whether or not a patent has business worth till the second or third renewal durations, forcing extra prices on an entity earlier than the worth of the patent is known. Burleigh supported upkeep and problem charge will increase of about 7 % to hold tempo with inflation.

Josh Malone, inventor of Bunch O Balloons, famous that the day’s listening to on payment will increase was “based on an unrealistic and aspirational value proposition,” specifically that the charges paid for acquiring a patent would truly end result within the grant of a patent which was backed by the complete religion of the U.S. authorities. Malone stated that whereas many inventors possible assume that they will get a patent for the difficulty charges of $1,200, the precise value of a patent is round $350,000, the median value for defending a patent on the PTAB. For inventors like Malone who’ve confronted multiple problem on the PTAB, that complete is even greater. “I know this is uncomfortable and discouraging… No one wants to be in the crowd when the child says that the emperor has no clothes,” Malone stated. “But this is no empire. This is America. You know deep down what I am saying is true. And you don’t have to accept it.” Malone then urged the management of the USPTO to be a part of him on Capitol Hill to request Rep. Darrell Issa (R-CA) to maintain a listening to within the subsequent month or two to talk about the integrity of the U.S. patent grant.

Steve Brachmann

Steve Brachmann

is a author situated in Buffalo, New York. He has labored professionally as a freelancer for greater than a decade. He has develop into a daily contributor to, writing about know-how, innovation and is the first writer of the Corporations We Comply with collection. His work has been revealed by The Buffalo Information, The Hamburg Solar,,, Motley Idiot and Steve additionally offers web site copy and paperwork for numerous enterprise shoppers.